PAST ABSTRACTS
Abstracts from SPT 2025
-
Ben Wilby, Manager – Offshore and Onshore Equipment, Westwood Global Energy
Status of offshore E&P
Offshore EPC market outlook
Flexibles and rigid pipeline opportunities
Regional opportunities
Future forecasts
-
Pieter Swart, on behalf of Gasunie
In 2022 the Dutch cabinet increased its targets for offshore wind energy in the North Sea to 21.5 GW to be realized in 2031. In 2024 the Dutch government indicated which wind areas will be realized before 2032. These are wind farms with a distance of up to 150km from the coast, whose energy will come ashore in electrical form (Direct Current/Alternating Current. With the further growth of offshore wind energy after 2030, the Dutch government intends that, besides electricity, hydrogen will also be produced from the offshore wind energy in the North Sea. With limited land-fall points, higher renewable energy capacity than demand, grid congestion, and a need for green gas carriers like hydrogen, large-scale offshore hydrogen production and transportation is expected. Integration of renewable power generation and conversion capacity and hydrogen transmission (e.g. lower pressure) involves very large investments and hence a well-designed infrastructure for hydrogen. Gasunie have conducted a feasibility study an Integrated Offshore Hydrogen Production System in the North Sea. The lecture will present Technical and Spatial aspects of the concept which fit within the future build-out of offshore hydrogen network up to 2050.
-
Grethe Malene Sagerup, Project Director - CO₂ Highway Europe, Equinor
Equinor CCS strategy
CO2HE value chain perspective including storage portfolio
Project status and what we have achieved so far
Challenges and opportunities going forward
External context – and what it will take
-
Authors: Lars Amdal (DNV), Leif Collberg (DNV) and Erik Levold (Equinor)
Determination of the required wall thickness of a pipeline is a simple task and can be made by pencil and paper in minutes. The challenging part is the follow-up design, what mitigations are required to meet all the other limit states for that determined thickness? First the design scenarios must be identified. What are the events to be designed for, what loads will these impose on the pipeline, what will be the response in the pipeline (the load effect) and are these within the capacity of the pipeline? Typically loads from the events may be taken from standards or recommended practices, the loads are then applied in a FE-model and the resulting response is checked versus design criteria in standards. These days engineers try to be smarter, but do we run the risk of fooling ourselves? This presentation will focus on for which scenarios may intervention work be reduced by more advanced FE-analyses, is the uncertainty in the applied loads similar to the resulting response uncertainty, can the capacity be determined by FE? The answer is, as often, ”it depends”. Many pitfalls will be illustrated!
-
Authors: Arek Bedrossian, Nikolaos Chatzimanolis – Subsea7, Sutton, UK
There are many pipeline loading situations where, according to DNV guidelines, the nature of loading must be classified as either ‘load controlled’ or ‘displacement controlled’, before assessing integrity. In cases where it is not clearly defined in the DNV code as to which condition prevails, load controlled is always advocated, as it ensures conservatism. However, this entails additional cost. The approach described in this paper helps eliminate the need to make assumptions regarding the nature of loading by applying the limit load method. The method, which is widely used in structural and pressure vessel design work, involves proportionally increasing all loads acting on the pipeline in a non-linear FE model and observing the resulting trajectory of the response. If the stable trajectory veers more towards strain limits, then it is concluded that the loading is ‘displacement controlled’. In the example of the escarpment crossing given in this paper, the limit load approach revealed the opposing contributions of local and remote effects on the trajectory. Local effects tend to exaggerate local bending of pipe over sharp protrusions, whereas longer range effects alleviate it. This balance between the two effects is captured effectively by the limit load, sometimes also called ‘design by analysis’, method. The results indicated that with minimal local intervention strain-based criteria can be used for the design of the escarpment crossing. The limit load approach reduced the need for costly bulk remediation measures. The method could potentially also find beneficial applications in other pipeline design and installation loading situations.
-
Author: Kok Siong SOON, Subsea Pipeline Engineer - Engineering Australia, McDermott
Co-author: Mr. Gravina, Senior Manager - Engineering, McDermott International (London)
This paper presents a comprehensive analysis of a mid to deep-water subsea project involving 8-inch and 10-inch pipelines using the J-lay approach. One of the main challenges is navigating the highly dense, pockmarked seabed with limited routing options. A Zigzag Routing using ZRB mitigation strategy is employed to ensure the pipelines avoid pockmark excursion zones while achieving high reliability of planned buckles and reducing the probability of rogue buckles, in accordance with codes, standards, and customer/project requirements. Corrosion-Resistant Alloy (CRA) Hot Rolled Bonded pipes are used to mitigate buckling risks, while mechanically lined pipes (MLP) with different wall thicknesses are chosen for non-buckling zone, offering a cost-effective solution without compromising safety for sour service pipeline. The project also tests the integrity of field joint coatings, confirming their efficiency and leading to their adoption. The project addresses slugging fatigue challenges along the entire route, particularly at the spans of ZRB triggers. 3D Finite Element Analysis (FEA) using ABAQUS software, with Tube-in-Tube (ITT) elements, is utilized to understand the complex interaction between pipeline dynamics and seabed conditions, capturing long-term integrity within lateral buckles. The impact of walking and buckling due to high pipe-soil interaction at localized pipeline embedment is reviewed through the pipeline touchdown profile. The use of Pipe-Clamping-Mattress (PCM) and an Equivalent Friction method in FEA improves efficiency and accuracy.
These methodologies collectively ensure the subsea pipeline project's success in installability, maintaining pipeline integrity and reliability under challenging deepwater conditions.
-
Authors: D.A.S.Bruton (Crondall Energy); C.M.Martin (Oxford University); M.Witz (Crondall Energy)
For most on-bottom pipelines, lateral buckling is virtually inevitable, and the design objective is to control the buckling process by initiating buckles in pre-determined locations.
In operation, lateral buckles cut a trench bounded by soil berms. Numerical simulation of this behaviour is a significant simplification, being based on horizontal sweeping under constant vertical load with springs to represent soil berms. In reality, as the pipe moves laterally it displaces vertically. The apex of the buckle cuts a trench, inflection points form as the pipe rotates, and vertical contact forces vary along the length of the lateral buckle while the soil berm restraint is load-controlled.
The authors have developed a state-of-the-art modelling approach that simulates transverse pipe–soil interaction on soft clay, using sequential limit analysis for multiple 2D slices of soil attached to a 3D structural model of a pipeline undergoing lateral buckling, running within existing Abaqus FEA software. This approach has been used to evaluate field examples to:
Compare predicted fatigue damage with traditional analysis methods, quantifying design conservatism.
Assess the response of soil berms, to identify more appropriate berm resistances.
Model ‘heavy’ pipe, which traditionally requires mitigation such as buoyancy.
This modelling approach has the potential to become the software of choice for assessment of the most challenging pipelines. Capturing realistic predictions efficiently and robustly, it has the potential to make significant savings on mitigation costs.
-
Authors: Marco Puliafito and Rupert Rowland, Subsea7
Co-authors: Ashley Ruthnum, Danijel Mijic, Zoran Vidovic and Stylianos Panayides, Subsea7
Routing subsea pipelines through steep and rough escarpments presents significant challenges. Ensuring the integrity of these pipelines can be challenging, and seabed interventions are often necessary. This paper provides an overview of a project Subsea7 has executed where the seabed along one 16-inch and one 12inch trunkline routes presented significant challenges. The trunklines crossed an extremely steep and rough escarpment, characterized by a network of canyons with high longitudinal and transverse slopes, scattered vertical features, variable soil conditions and rock outcrops. Engineering and operational activities were undertaken to plan and execute the necessary seabed rectifications to achieve adequate route profiles for the safe installation and operation of the trunklines through the escarpment. The standout achievement of this operation lays in the scale and complexity of the seabed rectifications required and the efficient engineering and operations which were carried out over a tight schedule of less than one year. To meet the project schedule, design, procurement and offshore operations were performed in parallel, necessitating exceptional coordination among all parties. This included planning for alternative seabed rectifications, such as rock installation or excavation, depending on the seabed features encountered offshore. The engineering activities focused on pipeline routing optimization, on-bottom roughness analyses, and geotechnical assessments. Operational activities included the mobilization of multiple subcontractors, development of robust procedures including detailed decision-making protocols, and continuous multidisciplinary offshore engineering support.
-
Author: Akash Arun, Graduate Engineer, Peritus International
Typically, governing criteria for pipeline tie-in spool design include allowable loads on the riser bottom flange. This paper presents a project case study where Peritus undertook detailed pipeline tie-in spool design for an offshore Angola platform. Initial riser and tie-in spool modelling showed computed loads exceeded riser bottom flange limits. A major factor was the riser’s transition into static equilibrium after installation (i.e., riser bottom flange weight taken by the spool swan neck). In reality, risers are installed before spool connection; the riser bottom flange remains unstressed until spool attachment, at which point interface loads develop due to component interaction. Capturing this sequence in industry-standard software is challenging, as typical spool modelling programs lack sequential static analysis capability. To address this, an optimized methodology used separate models. First, the riser is analysed alone to determine its as-installed configuration. Separately, a spool-only model with a fixed-end boundary condition calculates interface loads. These loads are then applied to the riser to determine its local stiffness at the interface. Finally, the spool model is revisited and reanalysed with computed stiffness, refining interface loads. This iterative approach better represents real-world installation conditions, reducing excessive conservatism from modelling riser and spool together. In this case study, it resulted in acceptable flange loads and a satisfied client.
-
Author: Tanzil Ali Khan, Rigid Pipeline Discipline Manager, Subsea7 Malaysia Sdn Bhd
Flow Induced Vibration (FIV) poses significant challenges to the integrity and performance of offshore structures, particularly rigid vertical jumpers suspended above the seabed. Fatigue damage due to FIV often leads to potential fatigue failure of girth welds. This paper investigates the use of buoyancy modules as an innovative and effective mitigation strategy for FIV fatigue in subsea rigid jumpers. Numerical simulations based on project data assess the performance of buoyancy modules in altering the structural natural frequency response, thereby reducing vibration amplitudes and associated stresses. While the use of buoyancy modules to reduce stresses and tie-in loads during normal operation is common, their strategic placement along rigid jumper legs to mitigate FIV fatigue is relatively novel. The paper introduces the fundamental principles of FIV, calculation methods, and its detrimental effects on subsea rigid vertical jumpers. It then presents the design and concept of buoyancy modules as an innovative approach to dampen FIV, incorporating fluid-structure interaction and various operational and environmental conditions. Finite element analysis and advanced computational fluid dynamics (CFD) techniques in the frequency domain are used to examine the effectiveness of buoyancy modules in mitigating FIV fatigue. Case studies from live projects demonstrate the practical implications and benefits of utilizing buoyancy modules on subsea rigid jumpers, considering constraints such as cost, impact on jumper tie-in loads, and vortex induced vibration (VIV). The results highlight the promising potential of buoyancy modules as a viable solution for mitigating FIV in subsea rigid vertical jumpers, providing valuable insights for enhancing structural integrity and safety in offshore engineering.
-
Author: Moeen Nazari, IKM Ocean Design
Over the last years, the frequency of incidents in Baltic Sea causing damage to pipelines, and telecommunication and power cables has increased. Considering these events and developments in the geopolitical situation, establishing a rapid repair procedure is crucial to ensure that the damaged pipelines and cables are back in service swiftly. In October 2023, the Balticconnector offshore pipeline sustained damage due to a dragged anchor incident, causing a rupture that required repairs. The damage occurred in 60 meters of water depth, within a section of the pipeline surrounded by third-party asset crossings. As a result, the pipeline was displaced from its original course and dislodging rock berms installed at nearby crossings. Given the critical importance of the pipeline and to minimize the shutdown period, repair operations had to begin within weeks. As a result, the lift and shift, in-place, and geotechnical analyses, were conducted almost simultaneously with the offshore operations. To lift and shift the damaged pipe into the repair position, lateral barriers were required to function as turn points. In addition, foundations at 5 locations for heavy subsea repair equipment, with submerged weights ranging between 30 to 72 tonnes, were required. Only limited number of concrete log mattresses were available to be used as foundations on a seabed with extremely soft clay on the top 2-3 meters. This paper outlines the design of the lateral barriers and foundation solution for the repair frames, developed within a narrow timeframe and under significant constraints, including limited equipment, environmental challenges, and the inherent practical limitations of the subsea operations in an area with heavy marine traffic. For the lateral barriers, a combination of clump weights and filter units was proposed and implemented during lift and shift operations. Additionally, an optimized arrangement of two-layered concrete log mattresses was designed for heavier equipment, while single-layered mattresses were used for lighter ones. The lateral barriers and concrete log mattress foundations performed successfully during both the lift and shift, as well as repair operations. Balticconnector repair operation is considered one of the most successful in its kind. As a result, the pipeline was restored to service in April 2024.
-
Author: Alberto Battistini, Advanced Analysis Dept., Saipem
The In-Service Buckling design of offshore pipelines is widely carried out using probability-based approach to ensure a high reliability for planned buckles formation and an acceptable post-buckling configuration in terms of deformation and loads. The Pro-Buck program is a MATLAB-based tool for analyzing the probability of buckling in pipelines subjected to axial loads induced by pressure and temperature. By calculating critical buckling loads (CBLs) and providing valuable insight into critical points where buckling may occur, Pro-Buck helps evaluate pipeline stability under various conditions. The program uses a Monte Carlo algorithm to capture Virtual Anchor Spacing (VAS) and buckling frictions, generating detailed results that include Characteristic VAS, and pipeline expansion. Pro-Buck introduces an innovative approach that could apply minimal changes to the DNV-RP-F110 methodology and recommendations. It determines soil friction distributions at expected buckles and addresses significant limitations of the traditional approach by sampling lateral friction and out-of-straightness (OOS) factors separately. This separation leads to a more accurate and reliable assessment of buckling risk, resulting in significant cost savings and improved design reliability. Pro-Buck also integrates the calculation of buckling propensity from bathymetric survey data. The results obtained with the Saipem software (Pro-Buck) for one project were successfully replicated with BuckPy, validating both codes and establishing a benchmark for BuckPy. The results from both tools were identical, demonstrating their reliability and accuracy. The paper describes the main capabilities of the probabilistic tool with a focus on the proposed novel approach and potential implementations in DNV-RP-F110. An application is described to highlight the potential benefits in using this advanced engineering tool.
-
Authors: Adel Jebali, Aubin Malassagne and Wiem Labbene, TechnipFMC. Rafael F. Solano and Antonio P. G. Romero, Petrobras
Designing controlled lateral buckling for subsea rigid pipelines is crucial for exposed HP/HT flowlines. This design phase typically happens during the project's detailed stages and has been standardized thanks to guidelines (SAFEBUCK JIP, 2015) and recommended practices (DNV-RP-F110, 2021). Triggers such as steel sleepers, distributed buoyancy modules, and the residual curvature method (RCM) initiate controlled buckles. Managing rogue buckles caused by inherent horizontal out-of-straightness (HOOS) from the pipe laying process is a significant challenge. These rogue buckles can lead to conservative designs or reliability issues, as standards cannot cover specific as-laid HOOS for each project. Overestimating triggers to avoid competition with rogues may jeopardize pipeline and equipment integrity significantly. The HOOS and actual flowline routes can only be assessed after post-processing the as-laid survey. Detailed as-laid Finite Element Analysis (FEA), which takes considerable time, is often done after the pipe laying. This creates a significant challenge, as waiting for extended FEA to start production is impractical. Unlike free span corrections, lateral buckling contingency measures to avoid rogue buckles are rarely planned because the as-laid FEA reassessment outcomes come too late. This paper compares a simplified qualitative method using RCM as the main trigger for a deep-water project with an as-laid detailed FEA based on survey data. It also addresses a contingency plan designed before the installation campaign, which was applied due to quick results from a simplified curvature check performed hours after the as-laid survey.
-
Authors: Ismael Ripoll (Xodus Group) and Carlos Sicilia (TotalEnergies)
The lateral buckling design of surface-laid, subsea pipelines can be optimised by using probabilistic design methods. In areas where the seabed has limited vertical unevenness, the key inputs used in these Monte Carlo simulations are the probability distributions for the pipe-soil interaction and for the lateral out-of-straightness features (OOS). For the pipe-soil interaction response, physical models have been developed based on experimental work and geotechnical principles and distributions can be predicted if adequate geotechnical data is available. For the OOS features however, it is not possible to make predictions based on engineering principles, since these features are the result of random deviations from the intended pipeline route during pipelay. Instead, for this parameter, the industry mostly relies on the empirical distributions that were developed by the Safebuck JIP, based on OOS data from pipelines installed before 2014. These distributions are currently presented in DNV-RP-F110. The approach used in the Safebuck JIP to quantify OOS features consists in performing Finite Element analyses of sections of as-laid survey data to determine the axial force at which a buckle forms (with a certain lateral friction). The ratio of this force and the value predicted by a reference analytical equation (with the same lateral friction) represents the effect of the worst OOS feature in the section analysed. By repeating this process for many sections of survey data, distributions of OOS features can be developed. This paper presents the processing of OOS data from actual projects, following the Safebuck approach. Sensitivity analyses are performed to evaluate the robustness of the approach to quantify OOS features, including the breakout and residual lateral friction and the mobilisation displacements considered in the FE analyses. The sensitivities also consider the robustness of the approach with regards to the scale length considered in the analyses and the appropriateness of the reference analytical equation. Based on these results, the paper proposes a detailed methodology to produce a reliable quantification of the OOS features based on Finite Element modelling of the survey data.
-
Author: Jamie McPhail, Consultant Engineer and Subsea Commissioning Team Lead, Wood
Pre-commissioning and commissioning of subsea systems is a vital project phase where assurances are given that construction and installation of the subsea system has been completed correctly and that the systems are safe to start up. However, as this phase is generally the final phase before handover to the operations team, it is often not given the consideration it truly requires from project initiation. Project teams often fall fowl of seeking little to no input from the pre-commissioning and commissioning team until system designs have been finalised and manufacturing is underway with little to no scope for modification.
For the vast majority of subsea projects, the construction and installation campaign is the most expensive aspect for obvious reasons, however what many projects fail to realise is that subsea system pre-commissioning and commissioning can also have significant cost impacts due to the regular requirement for offshore support vessels, large temporary equipment spreads, significant volumes of speciality chemicals, and bespoke equipment such as temporary pig launchers and receivers (PLRs) etc. This paper aims to highlight the importance of early engagement with subsea pre-commissioning and commissioning teams and how this can have a significant positive impact on overall project delivery, cost and performance.
-
Authors: Alexander Guy, Erika Johana Tovar, Joakim Backlund, Anette Groven and Philip Flaherty, Halliburton
Alexander Knight, Sjur Hovelsen, Elena Voskresenskaya, Jarle Øverland, Kjell André Stensland and Svein Viggo Aanesen, Equinor
Masoud Ghorbaniyan and Ojonimi Samuel Haruna, NOV
Statpipe pipeline systems have been transporting rich and dry gas from several fields in the Norwegian North Sea to the Kårstø gas processing plant since 1985. To extend its service life, a new landfall solution was developed, consisting of a subsea tunnel for landing the existing pipelines with new pipelines in the landing tunnel on the seabed, connecting to a valve station onshore. This paper reviews the job sequence to make this operation successful.
The complex operations included decommissioning of the existing 28-in. and 30-in. pipelines, their mechanical isolation, cutting and tie-in to the new pipelines both subsea and onshore, and pre-commissioning and commissioning jobs in the novel pipeline systems. The process involved, in some cases, simultaneous land and offshore activities, and the utilization of a substantial amount of seawater flowing through the pipelines to be discharged to sea. One main challenge was supply and management of such large quantities of water and its post-treatment making it acceptable for discharge at this shoreline location, imposing very strict discharge limits (0.001mg/L) on Hg and Pb.
More than 20,000m3 of contaminated seawater was successfully filtered by a 7000m2 0.1micron ultra filtration unit, allowing all particulate matter to be removed which included ‘Black Dust’ particles, and other contaminants (such as mercury and lead), permitting a safe discharge into the open sea near shore. This amount of seawater, equivalent to approximately seven Olympic swimming pools was handled on the fly, assisted by some significant buffer volumes. This novel solution prevented potential project delays and mitigated subsequent economic and environmental impacts, such as CO₂ emissions. The consequences of unsuccessful water treatment would have been very significant and resulted in substantial time delays, cost impact and CO₂ emissions.
Utilizing this high-capacity ultra filtration unit for the first time in this application the Statpipe systems with 28-in. and 30-in. pipelines were successfully commissioned, enabling hydrocarbon transport, improving operational efficiency, and extending the service life until 2050 as planned.
This paper will discuss how intercompany collaboration, good communication, and engineered solutions enabled the safe and successful execution of a complex project with several operations. The project aimed to extend the lifetime of one of the most important pipeline systems in Norway, which transports hydrocarbons to Europe, while providing sustainable solutions.
-
Author: Antoine Marret, Technical Manager, Saipem
Direct Electrical Heating Pipe-in-Pipe (DEH-PiP) has been around since its development and installation by Shell in the early 2000’s. It is a well-known and field-proven solution for subsea flowline heating, but it exhibits a relatively poor electrical efficiency compared to emerging Heat-Traced PiPs. However, with some improvements, the technology can be a very competitive option for subsea flowline heating. As a result, SAIPEM developed a High-Performance version of the DEH-PiP by introducing two new innovative elements.
The first is an Aluminium Liner on the inner face of the Outer pipe. Most of the return current flowing in the outer pipe being channelled in this millimetric internal layer made of very conductive and non-magnetic material, the ohmic and hysteretic losses in the outer pipe are highly reduced. The electrical efficiency of the system, thus enhanced up to 95%, leads to:
Increased flowline step-out by lowering the voltage supply level;
Reduced power consumption when compared to classical Direct Electrical Heating technologies and thus reduced GHG emissions in production.
The second is an innovative solution to fulfil the shear stop function needed in a Pipe-in-Pipe, but without metallic bulkheads. Such bulkheads are then replaced by rigid and isolating mechanical links made of composite material allowing an improvement on the lay rate by 20% while improving thermal efficiency and safety in offshore operations.
-
Authors: Martin MacPhee, Senior Applications Engineer, GMC and Emilien Bonnet, Pipeline Engineer, Total Energies
Every steel grade has a water depth limit for riser system and pipeline catenary applications above which the resistance associated with thickness increases cannot compensate for the load from additional weight.
Mechanical connectors machined directly onto line pipes allow using higher steel grades without facing weldability issues, enabling development of deeper fields. Absence of girth welds furthermore significantly improve fatigue performances which are critical for riser systems in sour environments. A high strength, HPHT mechanical pin and coupling system, developed and tested by GMC Limited and Total Energies, is presented as a solution as an enabler for deepwater developments, whilst reducing project costs, removing welding, NDT and coating from the critical path (offshore installation phase). In addition to S-lay or J-lay vessels, the possibility to install from drilling ships can widen the range of suitable vessels as well as weather windows. Built on the success of the field-proven GMC pipeline connector, the hybrid ‘HC Series’ system incorporates a non-rotational, push-fit mechanical connector, with multiple gas tight, patented metal seals on the OD and ID. Designed for sour service and features independent Inconel gasket seals which interface with Inconel clad areas within the ID profile. The structural strength of the joint is provided by multiple rings of precision machined teeth, which engage to form a maintenance-free connection, made-up within one minute. It can furthermore be disconnected within the same timeframe for repeat re-use. Non-threaded design and tests under tension as part of make-up procedure ensures reliability of the connection.
-
Ryan Sangster, Managing Director, Paradigm Flow Services
Paradigm's Flexi-Coil® is an advanced, patented technology with over a decade’s successful track record of effectively resolving offshore pipeline blockages caused by hydrates, wax, asphaltenes, and sand.
The miniaturized composite coiled tubing design of Flexi-Coil® allows Operators to directly target challenging blockages from platform topsides, removing the need for subsea operations, vessel support, or diver intervention — a distinguishing feature of this technology. Flexi-Coil® is characterized by its capacity to navigate complex pipeline geometries, handling over 1,000 cumulative degrees of pipeline bends and an extended operational reach of up to 6 kilometres from the riser entry point. Upon reaching the blockage interface, the system employs high-pressure jetting to disintegrate obstructive deposits and facilitates debris circulation back to the production facility for separation and disposal. Unlike conventional steel systems, Flexi-Coil® utilizes a high-pressure, neutrally buoyant composite coil tubing, which enables traversal through intricate pipeline configurations and reach extended distances without the risk of abrasion or damage to pipeline and flexible riser internals. This results in a fully remediated system, restored to bare pipe conditions. This groundbreaking approach provides Operators with enhanced control over remediation projects, promoting a faster and more effective return to full production capacity. This presentation shall cover recent case studies that demonstrate Flexi-Coil’s ability to resolve complex flow assurance challenges using minimally invasive technology.
-
Authors: Dario Gravina¹,²*, Selda Oterkus¹, and Erkan Oterkus¹, ¹Department of Naval Architecture, Ocean and Marine Engineering, University of Strathclyde ²McDermott International
Stress corrosion cracking (SCC) in the presence of absorbed hydrogen is a critical failure mechanism in structural materials, particularly in high-strength alloys used in aggressive environments. Traditional finite element analysis (FEA) methodologies often fail to accurately capture the complex interplay between hydrogen diffusion, local stress states, and material degradation mechanisms. This study proposes an alternative FEA methodology in ABAQUS to model hydrogen-induced SCC by integrating hydrogen-enhanced decohesion (HEDE) and hydrogen-enhanced localized plasticity (HELP) as the predominant failure mechanisms. The proposed framework incorporates a coupled diffusion-stress analysis to simulate hydrogen transport and accumulation at critical microstructural sites, such as grain boundaries and dislocation cores. The HEDE mechanism is modelled by reducing the cohesive strength of atomic bonds in the presence of hydrogen, while the HELP mechanism is captured through localized softening and enhanced plasticity in hydrogen-rich regions. A series of user-defined material subroutine are developed to implement these mechanisms, enabling the simulation of crack initiation and propagation in dynamic hydrogen coverage (DHC) under combined mechanical loading and hydrogen exposure. The methodology is validated against experimental data from slow strain rate tests and fracture toughness measurements on high-strength steel and nickel based alloys. Results demonstrate the ability of the proposed model to predict crack growth rates, fracture paths, and hydrogen embrittlement susceptibility with improved accuracy compared to conventional approaches. The work provides a robust computational tool for assessing the integrity of hydrogen-exposed structures and offshore pipeline and offers insights into mitigating SCC in engineering applications.
-
Authors: Alasdair Clyne, Business Line Manager, Integrity Services, ROSEN (UK) and Michael Tewes, Head of Business Line Hydrogen and Future Fuels, ROSEN (Germany)
The energy transition towards the use of more sustainable fuels is gathering pace. From the pipeline perspective, this transition involves the building of new, or repurposing of existing, pipelines away from traditional methane (CH4) transportation to hydrogen (H2) as an alternative clean fuel, or carbon dioxide (CO2) with respect to carbon capture, utilisation and storage (CCUS). These drivers for alternative use of existing pipelines present pipeline operators and owners with new challenges in terms of maintaining pipeline integrity. For example, the potential embrittling effect of hydrogen on pipe steel is well known, giving rise to an increased threat from crack-like defects. In addition, there is a risk that both hydrogen and carbon dioxide can damage the ILI tools themselves, and pipeline operational challenges may be significantly more taxing when transporting these “new” products. This paper firstly summarises the available ILI technologies for the detection and sizing of crack-like defects, namely electromagnetic acoustic transducer (EMAT) and ultrasonic (UT) crack detection, together with their relative merits. The paper will then focus on EMAT technology, which was developed with gas pipeline operators in mind to avoid the need for a liquid batch. Finally, the paper will focus on the challenges to be overcome when running in different gaseous products, together with the specific challenges associated with crack inspection in offshore gas pipelines from both the technical and operational perspectives.
-
Authors: Ammar Al Helal, Curtin Corrosion Centre Curtin University
Tiago Kaspary – Cladtek Do Brazil Rio de Janeiro Brazil
Fatma Abdelghafar – WA School of Mines-Minerals Energy and Chemical Engineering WASM-MECE Curtin UniversityAhmed Reda – Cladtek International PTY LTD Perth Australia/Curtin University
The transportation of carbon dioxide CO₂ through pipelines is essential for large-scale carbon capture utilisation and storage CCUS projects. Carbon steel remains the primary material of choice due to its cost-effectiveness, strength, mechanical properties and availability. However, the long-term reliability of carbon steel in CO₂-rich environments is affected by corrosion risks, impurity interactions and material degradation particularly under dense-phase and supercritical conditions. Industry standards outline material selection, corrosion control and integrity management practices alongside various mitigation strategies. This review focuses on directly comparing these mitigation measures for carbon steel against the alternative of using Mechanically Lined Pipe MLP, considering both technical performance and economic feasibility.
The effectiveness of mitigation strategies such as stream dehydration, corrosion inhibitors, internal lining and advanced real-time monitoring techniques is evaluated in the context of CO₂ transport. The analysis highlights how these mitigations enhance carbon steel pipeline longevity and compares their performance to the benefits and limitations of MLP. Particular attention is given to the effects of dissolved water (below solubility limit), free water (above solubility limit), sulfur dioxide, nitrogen oxides and oxygen on material integrity, as well as the influence of phase transitions and pressure fluctuations. The distinction between free water and dissolved water is addressed, noting that free water promotes corrosion while dissolved water below the solubility limit does not pose a significant risk. The review also considers the economic and practical implications of selecting either CS with mitigations or MLP, ensuring a holistic perspective on material selection for CO₂ pipelines. Relevant gaps in current knowledge affecting material performance in CO₂ transport are also identified and discussed. These findings improve pipeline infrastructure resilience and ensure safer and more efficient deployment of CCUS technologies.
Abstracts from SPT 2024
-
Dario Li Gioi, Head of Strategy and M&A, Saipem Group
Market analysis and impact on the contractor community
Operating in a transitioning market, meeting new demands
New approaches and solutions to achieve enhanced cost efficiencies and greener operations
A look to the future
-
John Willcocks, Technical Consulting – Technical Director Oil & Gas, Wood
Overview of safety regulations
Typical hazardous area, land use planning and Qualitative Risk Assessment (QRA) outcomes
Impact of safety on the routing and facility layout
What are the code requirements for CO2 pipelines?
What are the CO2 specification inlet requirements?
How do the mechanical design requirements for CO2 pipelines differ from natural gas lines?
How do the line pipe requirements differ from natural gas line pipe?
What are the CO2 compressor requirements and TRL.
Implications of CO2 service on integrity management and operations
Discuss of impact on requirements for corrosion management, crack development, flanged connections, ESD, valves, inline inspection, SCADA and third-party interaction
Inspection, Maintenance and Repair (IMR) technology gaps
-
Authors: O.J.H. Wesselink, A.H.M. Krom and Pieter Swart, Gasunie
The Dutch government has set targets for the growth of offshore wind energy production at 50GW in 2040 and 70GW in 2050. In the letter to Parliament on offshore wind energy 2030-2050, the cabinet has announced that hydrogen production at sea is necessary for the successful and steady growth of offshore wind energy. To unlock the value of hydrogen production at sea, an offshore hydrogen network is needed, consisting of offshore electrolysis, compression stations, offshore pipelines, integration into the onshore network, and other electricity and energy infrastructure. At the same time importation of blue hydrogen may play an important role as well, especially in the early phase of the offshore network. In the HyOne project, Gasunie, the Dutch operator for Hydrogen en Natural Gas, is presently assessing the feasibility of an offshore hydrogen network, whereby various options are evaluated, including new built and potential reuse of existing pipelines. This paper outlines Gasunie's assessment, ensuring that repurposed pipelines meet integrity requirements and can be operated safely, both for onshore and offshore applications. This assessment is grounded in preventing the degradation mechanism known as hydrogen-enhanced fatigue defect growth. It entails effectively managing pressure variations or other fatigue loads to hinder the growth of pre-existing planar defects within the pipelines. The primary locations susceptible to these defects are the welds in the line pipes and the girth welds of the pipelines. The specific defects to evaluate depend on the type of fatigue loading involved. Once the service life, fatigue load type, and the types and sizes of defects are established through comprehensive study, the permissible fatigue load can be computed. This calculation is founded on a restricted degree of defect growth.
-
Frans Janssen, Production Development Manager, Strohm
The current operating envelope and track record of CF-PA12 TCP’s
What’s new: specific aspects of CO2 service and CCS applications
PA Hydrolysis, effect of contaminants in CO2 stream, Rapid Gas Decompression, phase transitions and temperature changes
Required and ongoing TCP qualification for CCS applications
-
Authors: Thorsten Holst and Casper D. Hansen, NOV Subsea
This paper describes a fully qualified direct electrical heating method, which offers unique flow assurance opportunities in flexible riser systems used for subsea oil and gas production. The carcass of the flexible pipe is used directly as the electrical heating element, which offers a highly effective way to heat up the bore content. This enables simplified subsea field architecture, significant environmental benefits (and cost savings) by avoiding abundant infrastructure, and thereby improves the business case for both brownfield extensions and greenfields. A thermal model of the flexible riser is used to calculate the electrical power required to ensure the desired thermal control dictated by flow assurance requirements. We will present the different building blocks of the topside AC power system and how these units can be designed to form a compact system. The electrical power is fed to the riser, where power connectors are integrated in the EX-approved topside end fitting. Optical fibres are embedded in the tensile armour layer of the riser and are used to monitor the riser temperature and provide feedback for the power regulation system.
We outline the electrical model of this heated pipe power system to present a case study with parameters descriptive of a realistic flexible riser installation. We use this model to highlight the robustness of some anticipated operational conditions, such as the case of an outer sheath breach and the presence of conductive formation water inside the bore. The operational philosophy includes all aspects of safety functions.
-
Authors: Rodrigo Signorelli, Tiago Kaspary, Ahmed Reda, Jessica Pisano, Suryanarayanan
Mechanically Lined Pipe (MLP) is an enabling technology for the development of corrosive oil and gas fields, as well as for associated applications such as CCUS. Besides the technical and sustainability aspects, one fundamental advantage of MLP to its traditional alternative, Metallurgically Clad Pipe, is its cost-effectiveness and greater availability. Current projects however do not fully explore the potential of MLP and the wide range of corrosion resistant alloys (CRA) that could be used to optimize project economics while remaining suitable for specific field conditions. Particularly in the Brazilian Pre-Salt reservoir, Alloy 625 has been the alternative of choice since its precursor project Guara and Lula. It has been applied ever since, even though PETROBRAS has recently indicated conditions that would allow for the alternative CRA to be used in some applications. This work explores the application of 254SMO (UNS S31254 / EN 1.4547) and 654SMO (ASTM UNS S32654 / EN 1.4652) as alternative liner materials for MLP fabrication. 254SMO is a consolidated material used in a number of offshore applications including high responsibility systems, as fire suppression with seawater, and heat exchangers, where seawater is used as coolant. It has presented with good weldability, excellent resistance to pitting and crevice corrosion and high resistance to stress corrosion cracking thanks to its high nickel content. 654SMO increased alloy content, particularly N and Mo, results in PRE exceeding 56, CPT > 90oC and CCT > 60oC, surpassing the staple Alloy 625. Both alloys enable significant savings on the cost of MLP, while allowing for a wider range of suppliers and CRA availability. Cladtek has manufactured liners and MLP with the combination of DNV450(X65) carrier pipes with 254SMO and 654SMO supplied by Outokumpu/Nyby. The results of the qualification programs are summarized herein. Other potential candidate alloys for MLP application and future developments are also discussed.
-
Author: Authors: Rui Rodrigues, Joost Brugmans, Jeroen Timmermans - Worley Offshore Energy
The demand for larger-and-deeper subsea pipelines has led our industry to push the limits for pipeline design, with particular focus on increasing collapse resistance. These developments have resulted in improved material and fabrication aspects, design formulations and availability of record-breaking installation assets. However, the criteria suggested/required by design codes and operator standards in early-phase desktop and feasibility studies, are not always in step with these developments. This paper highlights how early-phase design criteria and design scenarios can result in a negative conclusion regarding project technical feasibility before the latest technology developments are given due consideration. This paper presents experience from ‘real projects’ where we have studied feasibility of relatively large diameter (24-28 inch) pipelines in up to 3,000 meters water depth. On some occasions, the technology limits of fabricability are allowed and required to be fully explored while maintaining early phase installability criteria that ignores installation capabilities of today, thus negating the gains of the ‘cutting-edge’ materials and fabrication aspects. In other cases, unrealistic conservatism (albeit well intentioned) in assumed operating conditions will lead to too thick pipes, making them ‘too strong to be installed’ (i.e. too heavy), especially if ‘dated’ installation criteria is prescribed.
These criteria, in design codes and operator standards, surely have had a purpose and a historical context that is not explicit in the way they are redacted in present editions. Without compromising safety, the existing criteria could do well with adjustments or clarifications to accommodate the technological gains achieved by the industry.
-
Authors: Chris Cooper, TechnipFMC - Brian Molloy, Harbour Energy and David Kaye, TechnipFMC
The Talbot development project and the Affleck re-development project were executed as a combined single iEPCI. Both projects adopted a reeled pipe in pipe (PIP) system to transport hydrocarbons to the host platform. Because of the moderately high design temperatures and the inherent residual bending moment in the reeled pipe in pipe system, a strain-based design philosophy was adopted to verify the integrity of the inner flowline of these buried PIP systems. The residual bending moment arises because of the effects of plastic strain during reeling and is characterised by a self-equilibrating (opposing) moment between the two pipes. This residual bending moment may potentially interact with applied operational loads and modify the design limit states for the PIP.
The method of analysis presented in this paper has been adopted on many projects but is not widely documented in the public domain. This is addressed by providing a summary of the work undertaken on both the Talbot PIP system and the Affleck PIP system. The approach complies with the design recommendations in the commentary of DNV-ST-F101 and highlights how the residual bending moment in the inner flowline and outer carrier pipe in a pipe-in-pipe system can be considered for in-place design. In conclusion, this paper shows that the impact of residual bending moment on the integrity of a reeled and buried PIP system is negligible.
-
Authors: Linlin Jiao, Principal Engineer and Mário Caruso, Principal Engineer, DNV
Free spans on slender subsea structures on the seabed such as pipeline, umbilical and power cable might develop due to various reasons, e.g., seabed unevenness, scouring, crossing and end terminations, etc. Free spanning of these type of subsea structures is a typical concern of ensuring their integrity against static loads generated by seabed roughness, functional loads induced by internal temperature and pressure (if any), and environmental loads due to waves and currents. One of widely used methodology for free span design is according to DNV-RP-F105 Free spanning pipelines. This recommended practice presents models to predict the loads induced by dynamic environmental loads due to Vortex Induced Vibration (VIV) and direct wave action. DNV-RP-F105 was developed for rigid pipelines. Due to lack of direct guidance for free spanning of a non-rigid pipe on the seabed such as flexible pipeline, umbilical and cable, the industry also applies it to these structures. In this paper, the application of DNV-RP-F105 to flexible pipeline, umbilical and cable is investigated through case studies. The fatigue assessments are performed through FatFree, DNV developed software in compliance with DNV-RP-F105. The recommended practice applications and different modelling choices are introduced and discussed.
-
Ian Nash, Group Managing Director and Chas Spradbery, Director of Operations and Business Acquisition, Peritus International
In 2021 Peritus was responsible for the retrofit riser design of 4 CRA Clad risers in 55m WD for installation on a battered jacket face well underneath the topsides structures. The proposal for these risers from FEED was problematic, so Peritus developed a novel design and installation approach that significantly improved the speed of installation and risk profile. The presentation will cover:
Initial design and resulting construction issues
Alternative design optimised for installation
Final construction case study
-
Authors: Yi Yu, Kristen Rege and Sangga Ciptadi, Subsea7
The J-tube pull-in installation method has been used for connecting subsea pipelines to platform topsides in North Sea. When a rigid riser is pulled through a J-tube bend, there will be a large bending moment in the riser and large reaction forces on the J-tube. The J-tube bend will also lead to a very high pull-in force when the riser bending stiffness is high, especially for pipe-in-pipe (PiP) rigid risers. In this paper, the pull-in analysis and the subsequent result validation from installation for a challenging J-tube pull-in project with 10”/14” PiP rigid riser are presented. Initially, the analysis method using beam elements with tube-to-tube contacts in finite element modelling to simulate the pull-in process is presented. Secondly, as the topside structure, the J-tube and the J-tube secondary structure must be able to resist the pull-in load and reactions from the heavy PiP riser, measures to reduce the pull-in force and to optimize the analyses are discussed. With these measures, the predicted maximum pull-in force was successfully reduced to below capacity. The approaches to reduce the loads acting on the J-tube is discussed next, since the integrity of the J-tube and the structures must be guaranteed during the pull-in. The proposed solutions to reduce those loads are checked and verified subsequently. Finally, the seal installation method is described and the required seal installation loads are estimated. The analysis shows the seal can be installed by the proposed method. In the subsequent offshore campaign, the rigid PiP riser was pulled into the J-tube without damaging the J-tube or the secondary structure and the seal was installed successfully. The predicted pull-in force matches well with the on-site measurement. Therefore, the J-tube pull-in analysis methodology is verified, and the effectiveness of optimization measures are demonstrated.
-
Authors: C. Geertsen, A. Damour, ITP InTerPipe - Air Liquide - Nexans - RTE – L. Quéval, GeePs, CentraleSupelec, Université Paris-Saclay
Superconducting cables can provide a cost-efficient transmission link for the electrical power generated by offshore wind farms. Operating at higher current and lower voltage than conventional transmission cables, enables significant savings on the transformer stations. Superconducting cables need to be cooled to cryogenic temperature to achieve zero electrical resistance. This is obtained by hosting the cables inside well-insulated pipelines through which liquid nitrogen (LN2) is circulated to maintain the transmission link at ca. -200°C. Such a pipeline could be installed by reeling or towing. While the physics of such a system are relatively straightforward, the qualification and construction require a significant effort from companies across different industries. A consortium of significant players has been set up to address these challenges. These include Nexans, Air Liquide, ITP, Univeristé Paris-Saclay and RTE as a core. Each has a recognized expertise in its own areas and has a reputation for excellence (superconducting cables, cryogenics, pipe-in-pipes, electrical engineering and power transmission). The paper will briefly describe the technology and its economic rationale. It will then identify the main challenges and how these will be addressed within the framework of the cooperation. Use cases are currently focussed on the French market but can be applied to other sites.
-
Authors: Sean Murray, Sameer Chapgaon, Scott McAllan and Vynx Lim, Lloyd’s Register
The level of residual lay tension which should be considered in the design of a subsea pipeline has long been a topic of debate within the industry. The debate centres around the degree of conservatism to apply when considering residual lay tension in various design aspects. Take, for instance, the assessment of global buckling. The assumption of low levels of residual lay tension is often seen as conservative as this maximises the compressive axial force in the pipeline under operating conditions. However, if a high level of buckle reliability is required, the assumption of low levels of residual lay tension may result in an overestimation of the real buckle formation reliability. There is no question that, during installation, pipelines are subjected to large levels of tension and to maintain equilibrium residual lay tension in the on-seabed pipeline must be present during installation. Nevertheless, estimating the appropriate level to use for design is neither clear nor straightforward. Although industry guidance acknowledges the uncertainty surrounding residual lay tension, it does not provide guidance on how much residual lay tension can be lost or the mechanisms by which this loss can occur. This paper presents a literature review on this topic and summarises the mechanisms by which residual lay tension can be lost. The paper also presents results of parametric studies which investigate the effect of these mechanisms, such as lateral pipe movement, to quantify the levels of residual lay tension which may be lost.
-
Authors: John Canney and Chris Cooper, TechnipFMC
Upheaval buckling (UHB) of buried pipelines has been extensively studied for over thirty years. As computer hardware has advanced so have our assessment tools. Post installation survey data appears to have improved dramatically in recent years and industry recommended practices have matured. Our ability to quickly undertake several sensitivity studies in the short time frame between survey and rock dump means that, in theory, a more refined rock placement table can be produced. But with all these technology improvements are our UHB designs any better? Do buried pipelines still buckle in operation? Why are the safety factors for UHB often high? Does our predictive UHB design provide a good estimate of required rock volume? In other words, what do we really know about UHB and what assumptions are hidden within the methodology? This paper attempts to answer some of these questions by using a few case studies as examples. It provides a summary of some recent challenges on buried pipeline upheaval buckling design. It also takes a critical look at the input data used in the analysis. In other words, it attempts to distinguish between what we know and what think we know. Finally, recommendations are given for development opportunities that could lead to improved UHB design and hopefully, reduce project cost.
-
Author: David Bruton, Senior Advisor, Crondall Energy
Many pipelines laid on the seabed experience cyclic lateral buckling in three dimensions, and walking (stepwise ratcheting displacement along the axis of the pipe). Both mechanisms are caused by shutdown and restart cycles in operation, combined with one or more other driving mechanisms, including: seabed slopes, thermal transients, liquid drop-out, SCR tension, route-curve pull-out, ratcheting lateral buckles, and berm-encroachment at lateral buckles. All these mechanisms have been observed on operating pipelines. However, predicting the rate of walking and pipe behaviour in the design phase remains extremely challenging due to inherent uncertainties in the design. Chief amongst these are: (1) pipe-soil interaction under cyclic loading; (2) the uncertain operating temperature and pressure cycling, which will vary over time; (3) the installed condition, including levels of residual tension. This uncertainty has led to projects installing high-capacity anchors, typically of 100t or more to arrest walking - should it occur. The design approach also varies significantly from project to project and operator to operator.
Many pipelines do not walk, but those that do can present significant integrity management challenges. Lessons learned from back analysis of operating pipelines to quantify and explain the walking mechanism and rate of walk has led to a growth in understanding and experience that has helped to identify newly observed contributory mechanisms to pipeline walking. There are still lessons to be learned from the monitoring and observation of pipeline systems that behave well, and those that do not. Alongside this work, more efficient anchoring systems have been developed that can be retrofitted and allow the adoption of delayed intervention wherever possible, in what has become known as the “wait and see” approach (Observational Method). This approach is based on improved methods for continuous monitoring of pipeline walking to predict future response, and innovative retrofit anchoring solutions that limit unnecessary mitigation costs and avoid mis-placed anchors.
While operating regimes will always be difficult to predict, not helped by conservative flow-assurance predictions, work has progressed in other important areas: (1) the monitoring of pipeline walking with the pending installation of a WMS (Walking Monitoring Sensor). (2) much improved understanding of the cyclic soil response based on observations of real behaviour, and (3) the development of full 3D structural PSI modelling of a lateral buckle that compares very well with field observations of pipelines that have been in operation for many years.
-
Authors: Hamza Moustafa a; Ismail Zohdy a; Philip Cooper b; Kevin Williams b; Ramy Magdy A. Mahmoud b
a East Gas Company (EGC), Cairo, Egypt b Petrofac, Woking, UK
The Gulf of Aqaba Pipeline Crossing, designed and constructed between 2002 and 2003, stands as one of the earliest deep-water developments in the Middle East region. This 15km 36” pipeline transports natural gas between Egypt and Jordan. During the design phase engineers identified and addressed potential risks, including long free spans, seismic activity and hydrotest. Recognising the significant economic consequences of a pipeline failure, a robust Operation, Inspection, Maintenance, and Repair (OIMR) programme was established. This programme's unique strength lies in its consistency. For the past 20 years, the core operational and engineering teams, along with the inspection contractor, have ensured the pipeline's continued integrity through seven separate survey campaigns. This long-term collaboration has fostered a deep understanding of the pipeline's behaviour and enabled proactive maintenance strategies. The OIMR programme initially planned for a rise in interventions as the pipeline aged. However, the pipeline's integrity surpassed these projections. This success can be attributed to integration of observation and analysis. As industry knowledge around deep-water pipeline spans grew, so did the accuracy of the engineering models that analyse the pipeline's behaviour. The article provides valuable insights for long-term monitoring of span fatigue damage, effects of debris on the pipeline, seabed mobility, lessons learnt in coating repair, and also gathered observations on the establishment of marine life around the pipeline in a deep-water development.
The Gulf of Aqaba Pipeline Crossing was a groundbreaking project undertaken when deepwater development knowledge was still limited.
A robust Operation, Inspection, Maintenance, and Repair (OIMR) programme was proved to be a highly successful solution to effectively address the knowledge gaps and uncertainties.
Insights on how the “digital twin” structural model of the pipeline is updated after each survey, and monitoring of span fatigue damage as part of a wider long term integrity management programme.
Study of seabed mobility is important to predict freespan development and mitigation over long periods of time.
The accumulation of debris around the pipeline can have both positive and negative impacts on the pipeline mechanical integrity.
Monitoring of marine life development around subsea assets is very beneficial to artificial reefs studies and restoration of marine life even in deep water environment.
-
Author: Helene Sirnes, Leading Advisor Pipeline & Transport Technology Pipeline operations, Equinor
An extensive network of pipelines is installed in the North Sea and have been operation since mid-80’s.
Equinor has since the beginning of its existence had an internal competence centre responsible for integrity evaluations, inspection, repair, maintenance, and monitoring activities. The transported fluids vary between multiphase, dense gas, sales gas, condensate, oil, chemicals, and CO2 injection and the pipeline portfolio consists mainly of rigid pipelines carbon steel grades X65 and X70. This paper will discuss our maintenance philosophy and how a pipeline barrier management is applied in operation.
-
Authors: Andreas Boenisch, Managing Director InnetiQs
Offshore pipelines and rigid risers present challenges to inline inspection. Unlike onshore distribution lines, subsea pipelines have heavy wall lines, CRA clad lines, small volumetric defect detection, multi-phase and other challenges to the standard intelligent or tethered pig technologies. In addition to the challenges of offshore pipeline pigging, the progress in the transfer of offshore pipelines for hydrogen transportation creates a new demand for new defect detection challenges. Based on the offshore pipeline challenges and gaps, a novel electromagnetic technology has been developed and integrated into the intelligent pig to assist in filling the known inspection gaps. The developed electromagnetic inspection technology is discussed with its technical background, capabilities and future approach to support closing the gaps in offshore pipeline inspection. The novel technical capabilities achieved with the MagControl electromagnetic NDT solution are discussed, as well as the future aspects of the electromagnetic solution for the new detection challenges that the emerging fuel lines will bring. Flexible Risers are complex pipe configurations which at the same time are critical production assets for the offshore operations. Flexible risers limitations are mainly related to limited lifespan compared to rigid risers and potential risks associated with fatigue and corrosion. Regular inspection and maintenance are essential to ensure the safe and reliable operation of flexible risers in offshore environments. The complexity of the flexible riser walls and the variety of different type layer configurations of flexible risers demands external inspections being able to offer a variation of inspection and detection capabilities to support reliable integrity and life extension assessments. Established and newly field integrated inspection technologies with focus of wire corrosion, -crack, -rapture and annulus flooding detection capabilities are discussed and displayed over case studies. The different NDT solutions integrated in deep water operational robotic systems are providing high resolution data for detailed information of the flexible riser condition. The discussed selectable and adaptable inspection systems offer a systematic approach to enhance the integrity management of flexible risers, safeguarding assets, protecting the environment, and preserving the reputation of offshore operators. Through flexible, reliable, and effective inspection solutions it empowers operators to detect and address potential issues proactively, thereby minimizing downtime, mitigating risks, and optimizing the performance of flexible risers throughout their service life and beyond.
-
Authors: Henning Bø, Technical Authority, T.D. Williamson, Inc. - Stephanie Craig, Project Manager II, T.D. Williamson, Inc. and Hallgeir Foss Alsvik, Engineering Manager, T.D. Williamson, Inc.
The TDW inline isolation tool, the SmartPlug® tool, has achieved a significant milestone, completing a remarkable four-year isolation period. Inline isolations are temporary, ranging from short to extended periods, typically from a few hours up to a year. However, in a recent achievement TDW completed three subsea pipeline isolations in the North Sea, extending beyond three and four years, which exceeds previous records in the history of inline isolations.
During autumn of 2019, three isolation tools, were deployed for planned duration of 2.5 years. Until their retrieval in 2023 the 12-inch, 24-inch and 30-inch isolation tools had isolated the pipelines, without any instances of isolation failure. The 12-inch and 24-inch tools were retrieved after ~3.5 years of isolation, while the 30-inch tool remained in place for four years and 10 days. As part of a field redevelopment project, the three isolation tools were employed to avoid temporary decommissioning of the pipelines during the disconnect and replacement of multiple platform topsides and reducing the consequences of failure of heavy lifting operations above the depressurized pipeline sections. The redevelopment progressed successfully with the inline isolation tools time in situ eventually reaching the four-year mark. The isolation tools underwent periodic monitoring, validating their stability and confirming the absence of changes or fluctuations in the isolated pressures. DNV played a crucial role as the third party, involved in the qualification of the technology during engineering design review and testing. This paper details the activities leading to the execution of this groundbreaking achievement, with a focus on the 30-inch isolation tool, which currently holds the record for the longest time in situ.
-
Authors: Markus Ginten, Thor-Staale Kristiansen and Benjamin Kosten, ROSEN Group
In in-line inspection, complying with API 1163 system qualification standards is key to achieving high-quality data as a basis for sound pipeline integrity assessments. Operating within the essential variables determined in thorough test programs is crucial to maintain accuracy and reliability in data acquisition. This is applicable for conventional free-swimming inspections but also for tethered inspections often utilized for unpiggable pipelines. The abstract highlights the importance of data quality and operational efficiency utilizing tethered Ultrasonic Testing Wall Thickness (UTWM) tools. By optimizing data quality, operators can enhance their integrity assessment process, thus mitigating risks associated with pipeline failures. Adherence to API 1163 standards not only ensures regulatory compliance but also fosters industry confidence in inspection outcomes. Additionally, this abstract emphasizes the economic benefits derived from deploying tools with higher maximum allowable tool speeds, which minimizes production loss during inspections. Through streamlined operations, operators can reduce downtime and associated costs, thereby enhancing overall profitability. In conclusion, a synergistic approach that prioritizes both data quality and operational efficiency is essential for maximizing the effectiveness of tethered in-line inspection methodologies, ultimately contributing to the sustainability and reliability of pipeline infrastructure.
-
Author: Kristen Andrew Foshaug, Chief Technology Officer, Connector Subsea
Deep water pipeline repairs are some of the most challenging operations in the offshore industry, yet the market increasingly demands cost effective, simple and robust solutions solutions. The MORGRIP pipeline repair product range has a 30- year track record of pipeline repair, with an unrivalled number of these being in deep water. These include numerous worlds’-firsts – such as the first diverless rigid riser spool replacement. For extensive damages to a pipeline it is necessary to cut out and replace with a new spool section which is subsequently connected into the existing pipeline with MORGRIP Connectors. For less extensive repair scenarios or life extension measures a MORGRIP Pipeline repair clamp can be used. CSS will present a recent case study of the 32-inch MORGRIP Pipeline repair clamp with the following operational parameters: Installation depth: 2200m Test pressure 403 barg Installation angle: 30 degrees. CSS have through many years developed pipeline repair clamps starting from an ROV’s operational perspective. This presentation will highlight reasons for major changes in design and operation when moving from diver installed to diverless installation.
Abstracts from SPT 2023
-
Authors: Toby Bird, Principal Engineer, Subsea 7 - Paul Westwood, Principal Engineer, ROSEN - Frank Bijster, Senior Sales Manager – North Western Europe & Israel, ROSEN
This paper will present how a flowline and topsides have been designed to reduce CAPEX costs to while ensuring the safety and integrity monitoring of the flowline based on material selection. Subsea infrastructure, and in particular pipelines, need to be carefully evaluated for throughput piggability point of view. This is to ensure that the pipeline will satisfy the regulatory requirements for integrity monitoring. With deeper wells come higher pressures and temperatures, which often leads to exotic material selections with increased wall thicknesses and therefore higher project cost. Minimising CAPEX is repeatedly the aim of the pipeline design team whilst ensuring safety is maintained throughout the pipelines design life. Located in the Norwegian North Sea, the unmanned Fenris platform is approximately 50 km north of the Valhall field centre and has shut in wellhead conditions of 862 bar and 170°C. The pipeline system has been designed in 2 sections that complies with the DNV guidance for HIPPS protected pipelines. This was achieved by very close collaboration between the pipeline EPCI contractor, Subsea 7, and the proposed In line Inspection provider, ROSEN. The removal of the valves and PLR connections from the Fenris platform resulted in a major cost and weight saving for the platform design. This pipeline design also totally removed the need for personnel to access the unmanned Fenris platform for pipeline inspection operations on the 50 km carbon steel pipeline.
-
Authors: Aurelien Damour, Edgar Morishita Maeda and Emmanuel PEREZ, ITP Interpipe
An operator in West Africa has requested ITP to improve its field-proven rapid J-lay Pipe-in-Pipe (PiP) for temperatures higher than 100°C or even 125°C. Currently, ITP Interpipe’s offshore field jointing system for PiP (more than 400km already in operation in West Africa and North Sea), uses a fast-curing polyurethane resin for load transfer across the field weld during J- or S-lay installation. This resin has the benefits of being a fast-curing material that will have little impact on the barge laying rate (3.5km/day achieved installation rate) but it has a limitation in term of design temperature in sea environment.
To increase the capacity of this field-proven field jointing system, an alternate design is under qualification using a fast-curing grout specifically developed for this application. The use of a grout as several advantages compared to a resin: its Young’s modulus is more 10 times higher than polyurethane resin, and stable over the temperature windows from 4°C to 125°C. Also, the grout thermal expansion coefficient is similar to the steel thermal expansion coefficient resulting in limited thermal stress in the field joint in operation. This paper presents the progress of the qualification of this upgraded field-joint system. The first step of the qualification
was to develop a grout formulation to fulfill the technical requirements of the load-transfer material: curing time of ~5min, intrinsic mechanical properties suitable with installation and operation loads. The new material was tested following standardized grout testings to confirm its ageing properties. In parallel, prototypes were fabricated and tested to confirm mechanical behavior of the grout under high bending strain (up to 0.4%) and with alternate traction/compression cycles. Another important part of the qualification is to develop a process and associated equipment for mixing and injecting the grout on the laying barge offshore. The main challenge is the grout curing time that excludes most of the standard grout mixing and pumping process: the operational risk is too high to pump the grout already accelerated, therefore a configuration has been developed with the grout accelerator being mixed after the pump. The paper will present the status of the qualification with the results of tests already done and the remaining technical uncertainties to be covered.
-
Authors: Antoine Marret, Piotr Malota and Torgeir Helland, TechnipFMC
The Fenja Field is located offshore mid-Norway at a water depth of approximately 324 m, and consists of two separate hydrocarbon accumulations, the Pil and Bue reservoirs. The reservoirs’ fluid properties are challenging, and Neptune Energy concluded that the Electrically Trace Heated Pipe-in-Pipe (ETH PIP) Technology would be the best technical and economical option to develop and produce the reservoirs. This paper presents a high-level overview and outcome of the development, industrialization, fabrication and installation of the TechnipFMC’s second generation ETH-PiP for application to the FENJA field development. It also presents the outcomes from the ETH system performance test conducted during the final commissioning of the system. The new ETH-PIP v2.0 has higher electrical rating of 3.8/6.6kV to overcome the specificities of the FENJA field development including the long tie-back distance of 38km which makes FENJA the longest (and largest) ETH-PiP in the world. The installation was finalized in Summer 2021, with the complete system being connected and tested from the Njord A platform after it returned from refurbishment in Spring 2022. Final commissioning and validation of the ETH-PiP performances were completed early 2023.
-
Authors: Tiago Kaspary, Eduardo Menezes, Jessica Pisano and Paul Montague, Cladtek
Mechanically lined pipe has been a very competitive alternative to solid CRA pipe or metallurgically clad pipe for offshore and onshore pipelines conveying corrosive fluids, with decades of successful application. Cladtek´s innovative solution of cladding and machining the pipe-ends back in 2004 significantly improved MLP installability by addressing the associated challenge of fit-up with clad girth welds, having become the industry standard. In the years since, Cladtek has created a number of improvements to the product, including the fabrication and installation of the largest diameter MLP in offshore use in Nigeria and the fully lined rigid risers in the Brazilian Pre-Salt. In this paper, Cladtek discusses the history of its MLP in the industry, its understanding on the limits of its application - in particular through case studies and improvements in recent projects, addresses a number of ongoing developments in the fabrication and inspection of this product. Finally, opportunities for new developments are proposed.
-
Authors: Chas Spradbery, Peritus International Ltd and Terry Griffiths, Aurora Offshore Engineering
It is well understood that traditional on-bottom stability designs are over-conservative for small diameter items such as cables and umbilicals. Furthermore, that when cables are placed on rough or rocky seabeds the traditional methods do not adequately capture the interactions between the cable and the seabed. Therefore, a new approach to cable stability on rocky seabeds has been developed. This approach is contained within a new British standard BSI 10009, due to be published later this year. This presentation will cover the background research leading to the novel approach to seabed stability described within the standard, along with case studies demonstrating how the methodology as been applied in real world situations leading to both cost and risk reductions.
-
Authors: Dr. Chen Shen, Mamadou Ahmed-Kogri, Dr. Eric Giry, Richard Stableford and Dr. Diego Pavone, Offshore Subsea Engineering, Saipem
Reel-laying is a long-established method for installing rigid subsea pipelines and has an extensive global track-record. In comparison with J or S-Lay methods, reel-laying imposes large deformations which could trigger failure by buckling, fatigue or fracture. Pipe manufacture and pipeline fabrication are carefully controlled, but each pipe has a tolerance on geometry and materials properties. Saipem performed a programme of full-scale reeling simulations to develop an accurate computational model for use in reeled pipeline design. The reeling simulations included 12m long pipes cut in half with an accurate counterbore machined in one end before welding back together. This creates a union of carefully controlled strong and weak “mismatched” pipes. Materials testing was also performed. FE simulations using parameter-based material model was validated against the full-scale test data. The FE modelling allows the DNV “pipe mismatch failure curve” to be developed into a useful tool in the Pipeline Design Engineers toolkit.
-
Authors: M. Cerulli, M. Abdullayev, C. Cooper, TechnipFMC - Jonathan Stuart Bracher, Equinor and Pål Foss IKM
The Residual Curvature Method (RCM) has proven to be a very effective method to initiate controlled lateral buckling of exposed pipelines that are installed using reel lay vessels. Most pipelines installed to date that have adopted RCM buckle initiators were single pipelines. However, as the technique has gained maturity, it has started to be used for Pipe-in-Pipe (PIP) flowlines as well. This paper presents a summary of the work undertaken to demonstrate the suitability of RCM for the Equinor Kristin Sor PIP system, which is exposed to trawl interaction and where RCM buckle initiators were adopted to control lateral buckling. Key aspects of the interfaces between in-place design and installation engineering will be presented with particular attention paid to the uncertainties that need to be addressed to demonstrate the robustness of the solution. Along with the usual uncertainties considered in pipeline lateral buckling analyses, for example pipe soil interaction and bottom tension, other uncertainties specific to RCM installation are examined, including RC strains, curvature and RCM section rotation. The results of the assessment are presented, key challenges are discussed and lessons learned shared.
-
Authors: Leif Collberg, Jan Fredrik Helgaker and Erling Østby, DNV
Hydrogen gas as an energy carrier is predicted to play a key role in the global efforts to decarbonize. As part of the hydrogen value chain, pipelines are considered an attractive option for transportation, either for transportation of pure hydrogen gas or as a mixture with natural gas. In this context, both new pipelines and utilisation of existing infrastructure (re-qualification) are possible options. One contributing factor for the push on hydrogen pipelines it its potential ability to accumulate/store gas which is a very tempting aspect when connected to non-stationary generation like solar and wind. One interesting question arise; is there a need for any R&D for hydrogen pipelines with all the statements of “hydrogen ready” pipelines? In the on-going DNV JIP H2Pipe, a design level scheme has been proposed to differentiate designs depending on its maturity and knowledge ranging from low to very high. Today, DNV consider only the level Low, typically covered by AS;ME B31.12, to be sufficiently proven for design which excludes the majority of offshore pipelines. The design levels and the linked concerns will be presented. A discussion of concerns will also be given and the difference between “do not know/lack knowledge” and “not possible”.
-
Author: Colin McKinnon, Technical Director – Technical Consulting, Wood
• Code and regulation requirements for H2 service
• Operational safety risks and mitigations: hazardous areas, vapour cloud explosion, ESD, risk contours
• Emergency response: shut down and venting
• Hydrogen operations: SCADA, leak detection, visual inspection, testing
• Hydrogen integrity management: pigging, crack detection, repair
-
Authors: Kenneth Solbjør, Product Manager, Oceaneering - Gary Anderson, Senior Manager Sales, TD Williamson - Georg Johnsen, Principal Engineer, Equinor
Remotely operated vehicles (ROV) and support vessels are essential to support subsea pipeline operations, including subsea inline isolations. Subsea pipeline isolation operations require robust communication systems to control and monitor tool loading, tracking, activation and deactivation. Typically, the system is hardwired or acoustically linked to the platform or vessel, supported by the vessel ROV. The duration of the isolation will dictate the support vessel time on location. Advancements in remote communication technology in both the ROV industry and the pipeline isolation industry have shown how support vessel dependency in such operations can be eliminated. This paper covers an actual pipeline decommissioning project whilst keeping the downstream pipeline system operational, all remotely from an onshore location. The solution paired advanced pipeline isolation technologies with a resident, battery-powered, work-class E-ROV system with LTE connectivity. The combination enabled the subsea inline isolation to be performed via a remotely deployed EROV system from an onshore operations center, an industry first. By using the onshore remote operations center, the project team was able to collaborate, control and watch live operations through the remote EROV. The isolation tool communication system interfaced through the EROV allowing the tracking, activation, monitoring and unsetting of the tool subsea, direct from the onshore operations center. Removing the vessel requirement eliminated costs, improved safety and dramatically reduced the CO2 and environmental footprint of the isolation operation.
-
Authors: Suzaini Zainal Abidin, Helmi Ngadiman and Faizal Shahudin, PETRONAS
This paper summarizes the basic operational steps taken by PETRONAS to complete its first open sea to open sea offshore Horizontal Directional Drilling (HDD) at one of its pipeline crossing locations at KP 83.709 for its newly installed pipeline for project located at Java Sea, Surabaya, Republic of Indonesia. The pipeline is a 12-inch, 110-kilometer gas export pipeline from the “A” platform to Onshore Receiving Facilities (ORF), at a water depth of 5 to 6 metres below mean sea level (MSL). This paper describes in general the construction methodology and operational steps for using the HDD method to cross beneath the 18-inch buried live existing pipeline from open sea to open sea. To comply with the authority regulation, all pipelines located less than 13 metres below sea level and within shipping channels must be buried at a depth of two metres below the seabed, this HDD method was chosen instead of the typical subsea pipeline slipper crossing. The crossing has been carried out in a single drilled section measuring approximately 350 metres in length from the entry point (at Drill Barge, Barge #1) to the exit point (at Receiving Barge, Barge #2) located offshore. The clearance requirement for the existing 18" pipeline (buried 2 metres below seabed) is between eight (8) and ten (10) metres below the pipeline's bottom. The entire drill string length is approximately 610 meter including a 130-meter-long tail string coated pipes with 30mm thick concrete (at both side) which was pulled and laid on the seabed before Pipe lay Barge came to pick-up, tie-in and continue laying towards onshore. Despite numerous challenges and limited experience, the project was completed on time, within budget, and with no LTIF or TRCF. This paper will provide a guideline for future similar project undertakings on the selection of marine vessels and equipment, the overall safe operation, and the efficient method to execute the project successfully. Commonly, the HDD operation is performed on the land side for pipeline shore approaches or pipeline crossing purposes to avoid an open-cut method across any existing facilities/utilities (road crossing, building, river etc). However, in this project, the HDD operation was performed at the open sea crossing the existing oil pipeline.
-
Authors: Jean Malnory, DNV - Odd Reidar W. Boye, IKM Testing AS - Stein Rimestad, Equinor
The BM-C-33 gas export pipeline (GEP) is one of the deepest large-OD pipelines under development. The offshore field is located 200 km off the Brazilian coast, in 2800 m water depth in the southern part of Campos basin. It was early identified that water filling, system pressure testing (SPT) and subsequent dewatering would become operationally challenging and also have a significant cost impact.
The BM-C-33 project team has therefore with support from DNV assessed the opportunity for obtaining an equal - or better - integrity level without performing SPT for its GEP. The project has adopted the methodology developed as part of the Replace JIP and the resulting guideline issued in 2020. The JIP REPLACE guideline is based on DNV-ST-F101 allowing replacement of the SPT of a pipeline system with alternative means while keeping an equal or better safety level.
This paper will present the REPLACE methodology adopted by the project; more specifically, what were the motivations for BM-C-33 and the implementation process - including checking consequences of the system design and the added safeguards through a semi-quantitative risk assessment. This semi quantitative risk assessment demonstrates that these proposed safeguards ensure an equivalent or better safety level.
Development of the Pre-commissioning (PCO) Philosophy for BM-C-33 will thereafter be presented, outlining essential conditions, assessments and specific solutions implemented to conform with the REPLACE guideline. A comparison with a conventional PCO solution will further be made, identifying the main upsides with REPLACE for BM-C-33
In total, the paper highlights how the REPLACE methodology can represent a potential gamechanger for certain projects. The new methodology offers significant advantages particularly for large-OD, long and deep pipeline systems. Avoiding water filling may provide a long range of upsides with regards to offshore operations, environmental impacts (chemical usage), equipment spreads and in-field logistics.
-
Authors: Svein Are Løtveit, Senior Advisor and Founder, 4Subsea and Morten Eriksen, Senior Advisor, 4Subsea - Arne Dugstad, Chief Scientist, Institute for Energy Technology
This paper presents a best practice for corrosion assessment of flexible pipes. The best practice is based on the two flexible pipe corrosion monitoring (FPCM) projects. The objective was to understand the annulus chemistry and the corrosion mechanisms and to give best practice guidance to integrity assessment and monitoring. The FPCM-II project included the following partners: 4Subsea, Project management - A/S Norske Shell, Okea AS, Equinor ASA and Chevron U.S.A. Inc, Industry sponsors - Institute for Energy Technology (IFE), R&D partner.
Corrosion of the steel armour wires is one of the most important mechanisms limiting the safe service life of flexible pipes. In an oxygen-free annulus with water present, confinement combined with large steel areas and low water volumes normally leads to very low corrosion rates. In some upset conditions, the corrosion rate may be high, and the best practice gives guidance for evaluation of these. The FPCM II Best Practice also considers various corrosion scenarios, supporting tools, evaluation methods and topics relevant to risk evaluation.
-
Authors: Danny Krogh Nissen, Technical Manager, Development and Qualification, NOV Flexibles Denmark and Kasper Lund, Metallurgist, Materials and Testing, NOV Flexibles Denmark
When operating in high CO2 applications, unbonded flexible pipes reinforced by conventional carbon steel are exposed to the risk of stress corrosion cracking (SCC), resulting in integrity failure, or significant service life reduction. This is relevant for conventional offshore O&G production and the emerging field of carbon capture, utilization, and storage (CCUS). The corrosion resistant flexible pipe provides an extension to the safe zone on conventional flexible pipes by eliminating the SCC risk and securing full-service life, while in all other aspects behaving as a conventional flexible pipe. The objective of this paper is to present the qualification evidence for flexible pipes with a highly corrosion resistant, high strength steel grade replacing the carbon steel armour wires with identical wire profiles and verifying the use of consolidated flexible pipe methodologies and processes. An extensive risk assessment has been performed, resulting in +65 individual identified threats, endorsed by Independent Verification Agency, covering dynamic HPHT deep water applications. A substantial amount of material qualification has been performed, showing suitability within; CO2 stress corrosion cracking, sulfide stress cracking (SSC), crevice corrosion and hydrogen embrittlement, pitting resistance, biocorrosion, and much more. A complete prototype pipe has been manufactured, and full-scale tests have been successfully performed, showing excellent compatibility with existing manufacturing processes and design methodologies. This paper will present the outcome of the FMEA sessions, summarizing the outcome of 5 separate qualification plans leading to full-scale product validation.
-
Authors: Barry Marshall, General Manager and Jan Stander, Managing Director, Aisus
The energy industry has for many years been seeking solutions to the complexities of integrity management of pipeline assets. Unbonded flexible risers have been a particular difficulty, and the introduction of fully bonded composites creates new challenges for integrity management. Until now, the lack of a practical and effective inspection method has forced integrity management to be based on engineering models and statistical predictions using extremely limited inspection data. Inspection data from a small sample area of a pipe system has had to be assumed to be representative of the overall pipe condition for integrity management. The data is used to predict the overall condition as well as the life expectancy of full complex pipeline networks, by statistical analysis rather than actual evidence. Additionally, new pipe designs and complex pipe structure such as Unbonded Flexible Pipe and Thermoplastic Composite Pipe (TCP) have been introduced to the market. These have essentially been ignored for inspection because regulators have deemed them un-inspectable, as no technology existed to inspect these new pipes due to their multi-layered complex constructions of non-metallics. This white paper explores how new high-speed x-ray technology is transforming the industry, making it possible for the first time to scan the full length of spoolable pipes while providing almost microscopic-level insights. This enables manufacturers to provide greater assurances and quality control to clients and gives operators a traceable digital record for the full lifecycle of the pipeline. Any changes to the pipe condition can be detected and monitored, providing data that gives confidence in the life of asset predictions, as well as enabling feedback to designers, manufacturers, and regulators. The end result is a dramatic reduction in Risk and an elimination of in-field failures.
-
Authors: Gilles Gardner and Adam Armstrong, The Impulse Group
Topside end fittings of unbonded flexible risers are designed with annulus vent ports that serve two purposes; to safely vent permeated annulus gases and to allow integrity testing of the outer sheath. If these vent ports become blocked, annulus testing cannot be carried out and the build-up of gas has potential to rupture the outer sheath allowing seawater to flood the annulus resulting in corrosion of the structural steel components of the riser.
The Impulse Group has developed a method of inspection which utilises a small diameter articulating camera system that can be manipulated to travel through the annulus vent port tubing providing valuable insight into its condition. This method allows the full inspection of the vent port tubing to identify any debris or tube compression preventing gas release, allowing The Impulse Group to consider methods of repair to any blocked ports and re-establish a topside connection either by mechanical means or simply utilising a vacuum attachment. Application of various external fixtures also makes it possible to articulate the camera to the end of the vent port to inspect for localised corrosion of structural wires within the end fitting region resulting in detection of cracking and corrosion within the riser structural layers.
This paper describes the development and offshore deployment of the annulus vent port camera inspection system, cleaning of the vent port tubing and presents sample findings.
-
Authors: Ismael Ripoll, Xodus Group - Carlos Sicilia and Emilien Bonnet, TotalEnergies
Operation at temperature and pressure of exposed subsea pipelines results in effective axial forces which may cause lateral buckling. To perform the lateral buckling design, the subsea pipeline industry typically uses a combination of Monte-Carlo simulations and finite element analysis (FEA). The Monte-Carlo simulations are used to determine the longest virtual anchor spacing that can be reliably guaranteed (characteristic VAS), and FEA is used to determine the longest VAS with acceptable mechanical conditions (tolerable VAS). The lateral buckling design then needs to ensure that the characteristic is less than the tolerable VAS. In this context, this paper presents a Monte-Carlo algorithm which determines the soil friction distributions conditional to buckling, and then an approach in which the tolerable VAS is in turn determined using these conditional soil friction distributions. For pipelines in which the soil friction distributions provided by the geotechnical specialists do not always lead to buckling, the proposed approach may have a significant impact on the overall lateral buckling design.
-
Authors: Chris Cooper and Piotr Krawczyk, TechnipFMC
Engineers have been calculating the wall thickness of pipelines for years. It is often one of the first tasks to be undertaken in the design process and the initial calculation for pipe wall sizing to protect against the burst limit state is often considered to be one of the most straight forward tasks. DNV-ST-F101 provides an easy-to-use analytical equation to determine the burst resistance. However, it also includes a clause, which until very recently, has not been widely understood and therefore, rarely used in pipeline design. This clause requires the engineer to consider the effect of compressive true wall force on the burst resistance. Applying this clause is far from straight forward and has been the subject of considerable debate on a few recent projects. This paper provides an overview of the problem, before summarising an approach that may be adopted to address this code requirement. A few case studies are presented, and some practical implications discussed.
Abstracts from SPT 2022
-
Authors: Neil Agnew, Technical Support Manager – Pipeline Services and Peter Dixon, Regional Engineering Manager – Europe, Africa, Russia and Caspian, Baker Hughes Process and Pipeline Services
Baker Hughes Process and Pipelines Services (PPS) successfully completed the pre-commissioning campaign for Subsea 7 on the Tamar Southwest Project in the Levantine Basin in 2020. The Levantine Basin is located in the easternmost part of the Mediterranean Sea off the coast of Israel. Two pipelines, 10” and 16”, laying approximately 1,670m (5,479ft) below the surface and running a combined 17.4km (11.4 miles) were flooded, cleaned, gauged, hydrotested and dewatered. The pre-commissioning scope of work was split across two campaigns. Both campaigns involved novel concepts which proved to be successful and instrumental in the completion of the fast-track project. Firstly, the pipeline flooding, pigging, cleaning, gauging and hydrotesting were performed from the remote deepwater location with the Baker Hughes Denizen™ Subsea Pre-Commissioning unit. This iteration of the technology allowed for a faster and more robust hydraulic integration between the client’s remotely operated vehicle (ROV) and the Denizen system. Subsequently the pipelines were dewatered via a bespoke coiled tubing downline system with over-boarding platform. The vessel-based high-pressure air/nitrogen compression spread was double-stacked to reduce the footprint on deck. However, this generated significant engineering challenges regarding access and heat dispersion. Diligent engineering and yard trial phases by PPS allowed the challenges to be overcome off of the critical path and yielded a successful, fast-track, offshore campaign.
-
Author: Matthew Lloyd, Saipem Limited
Case studies are presented for detrimental torsional effects interfering with offshore installation operations. These include a flexible flowline installed to water depths exceeding 900m via a centrally positioned VLS and 14ʺ rigid flowline installed via S-lay to 500m water depth. Both challenges required different innovative solutions to find timely and cost-effective solutions within the offshore campaigns. Residual torsion in a reeled flexible, which had been stored for a significant time, impacted the first end termination landing onto seabed infrastructure. The challenge of operating in deep water is that any corrective alignment occurs vertically from above, as opposed to the more desirable lateral directions. An anti-rotation buoy pre-installed onto the 14ʺ flowline (500m from the head) collapsed, and the flowline rotated 90°, measured from the pipeline end. The rotation was observed to be induced gradually along 1.8km of flowline length. The flowline was to be recovered in a J-lay configuration, fitted with a termination assembly and laid down again. Therefore, to meet with the welding tolerances, the flowline rotation had to be mitigated prior to reaching the vessel hang-off platform. The paper highlights approaches for overcoming some of the issues presented in the scenarios and outlines the actions taken offshore.
-
Ed Pratt, Senior Rigid Pipeline Development Engineer, TechnipFMC
Plastic Lined Pipe (PLP), where a carbon steel (CS) host is lined with a polymer for corrosion protection, has been installed using the reel-lay method for subsea Water Injection (WI) applications by TechnipFMC for more than 25 years. As industry demand has grown for WI at high pressures, the global supply chain has tightened, resulting in price increases for corrosion resistant alloys. Using commodity polymers, PLP becomes an increasingly cost attractive solution. An improved, robust connection method is required to increase the operational range of this technology to high pressures, and alternate uses such as production fluids, H2 and CO2 transport and storage. A new press-fit connector technology has been developed per DNV-RP-A203 guidelines, with continuous DNV involvement. This method of qualification has delivered a reduction in time to certification of new technology, with feedback from the certifying body provided throughout, to reach DNV TRL5 endorsement. Qualification testing consisted of assembly of full-scale prototypes followed by exposure to life-cycle loading including; hydrotesting, reeling simulation, accelerated ageing with combined shutdown cycles, and fatigue cycles for dynamic applications. Further, connectors were tested for creep and cyclic loading. The press-fit technology was found suitable for high pressure, dynamic riser service and also low cycle service with lateral buckling, such as in high pressure/temperature injection systems. Following this success, the technology is compatible and may be used with other TechnipFMC developments in PLP technology, including hydrocarbon transport and future H2 and CO2 transportation.
-
Authors: Nikolaos Chatzimanolis, Gianluca Colonnelli, Pasupathy Ragupathy and David Kay, Subsea 7
This paper presents the method employed for carrying out Upheaval Buckling (UHB) FEA accounting for the effects of slurry on the pipeline response. In order to accurately capture the pipeline’s global post buckling response and minimise the cover requirement, the analysis accounted for the actual slurry layer thickness as it varied along the trench. A 4" MEG pipeline was trenched and buried along its route in water depths less than 350m for protection from fishing activities. The pipeline was trenched using jetting followed by eduction of fluidised soil and buried with crushed rock. A slurry layer of varying thickness settled over the pipeline after trenching as complete eduction was not possible at this site. The crushed rock was placed over this slurry layer and the pipeline. The level of penetration of the crushed rock into the slurry layer could not be reliably determined soon after the placement, when the cover requirement needed to be determined. With respect to UHB, the worst-case scenario considers that the crushed rock doesn’t penetrate the slurry layer whereas the pipeline can move upwards through the slurry layer with no resistance until it reaches the rock layer. This allows the pipeline's curvature to increase locally at locations where there is slurry and consequently the tendency and potential for UHB increases. Therefore, the downforce which is required to restrain the pipeline and the associated cover requirement increase due to slurry. The thicker and more uneven nature of the slurry layer, the more amplified its effect is.
-
Authors: Linlin Jiao, Principal Engineer and Kjetil Bergseng, Principal Engineer, DNV
Free spans on subsea pipelines develop due to various reasons, e.g., seabed unevenness, scouring, installation of artificial supports, crossing and end terminations, etc. Free spanning of subsea pipeline is a typical concern for pipeline integrity with respect to fatigue and local buckling (ULS) capacity. The fatigue herein is mainly induced by dynamic environmental loads due to Vortex Induced Vibration (VIV) and direct wave. The onset of VIV depends on the characteristics of spans, e.g., span length and gap. The span lengths are thus required to be monitored regularly and limited within design criteria. The widely used free span assessment method in industry is still a manual processing, going from simple screening criteria through to advanced calculations for each critical span configuration. Recently, DNV has developed an automated (digital) model for free span assessments which assesses the fatigue damage per KP location along the entire pipe. The advancements in data storage and processing supports automatically accounting for multi-span interactions and changes in free span configurations within entire survey history. So far more than 50 subsea pipelines have been assessed by DNV applying this digital model. This paper introduces the theory background of fatigue assessment in accordance with recommended practice DNV-RP-F105 Free spanning pipelines, outlines the application of digital free span assessment method in pipeline integrity management work, and presents the relevant fatigue results of two representative pipeline cases.
-
Authors: Kristen Andrew Foshaug, CTO and Nitin Patel, CSO, Connector Subsea Solutions
Anchor and holdback clamps are specifically designed to grip onto the pipeline to retain its movement and prevent pipeline walking, which left unchecked can cause cumulative axial displacement leading to potential failures at tie-ins or risers.
Traditional methods require the coating to be removed to enable a structural interface with the bare pipe. However, removing pipe coating and interfacing with the bare pipe in typical deepwater applications can carry significant risks associated with cold spots and corrosion, in addition to the challenge of removing coating in a deepwater environment.
This paper describes a clamp solution that grips directly onto the pipeline coating, dealing with challenges of creep of the thermal insulation as well as thermal expansion/contraction during operation cycles.
Features included in the CSS clamp solution
• Radial creep compensation allowing a high load input and catering for thermal expansion/contraction
• HISC and corrosion protection of springs
• High degree of coating confinement leading to optimized coating behaviour
• Radial activation of gripping
• Precise load control of gripping force to avoid local collapse of the pipeline and overstressing the coating
• Possibility of in-service inspection to verify creep values during the clamp’s lifetime
• Deepwater ROV-installable and retrievableAn extensive full-scale test and qualification programme was performed to validate important principles of the solution. After successful completion of the test programme, the order of two permanent clamps was sanctioned. The two clamps were installed successfully at 830m water depth in December 2020
-
Authors: F. Örberg, C. Geertsen and G. Salque, ITP SA, France and V. Niesen, Evoleap, USA
A joint venture between ITP-Interpipe and McConnell Dowell has recently performed an EPC project to design, fabricate and install a 1.8km-long subsea electrically heat-traced pipe-in-pipe (EHT PIP) pipeline connecting two refineries across a navigable marine channel in Southeast Asia. The pipeline will transport highly viscous bitumen and its EHT system can be used to reheat the fluid from ambient to its min. flow temperature or maintain it indefinitely at min. flow temperature in case of shutdown. The line is designed to a temperature of 228°C, the highest for a subsea pipeline to date. The author will provide feedback from the construction which required accurate staging of multiple onshore and offshore sequences, namely:
• Onshore fabrication
• Marine and civil works (performed in parallel)
• Tie-in, pre-stress and commissioning operations -
Authors: Callum Peace, Nick Waple, Harry Cotton, Luke Swan and Hooman Haghighi, Wood plc
The drive for energy transition is currently underway, with many projects looking to convert or develop new facilities for integration into existing infrastructure. Governments are increasingly recognising hydrogen technologies as tools to meet decarbonisation goals. Hydrogen can be moved in a variety of forms, including as a pressurised gas, shipped in tankers as a cryogenic liquid at -253◦C, and in the form of hydrogen carriers such as liquid ammonia or methylcyclohexane-MCH. These options introduce unique challenges and obstacles to overcome to allow for practical and efficient transportation. Wood has conducted a review considering International pipeline codes/standards to determine their applicability to Hydrogen Service. One code, ASME B31.12, lists Hydrogen specific material requirements replated to hydrogen embrittlement, toughness degradation and increased fatigue crack growth rate of steel and is currently considered the governing code for H2 service. Case studies were undertaken for the repurposing of offshore natural gas pipelines for gaseous H2 service considering various levels of material qualification. Moreover, a range of flow modelling were carried out in order to compare the achievable energy flow/capacity of natural gas vs hydrogen (as energy carriers) for different scenarios by considering the design and operational constraints for such systems. This review also considers the readiness of the industry to provide pipeline technologies for the transportation of each hydrogen vector, including carbon steel qualification to ASME B31.12 and insulated pipe qualification for liquid hydrogen at cryogenic temperatures not seen within traditional hydrocarbons. Additionally, operational constraints and considerations associated with each option have been addressed.
-
Authors: T. Guegan and C. Geertsen, ITP SA, France and Supernode, Ireland
Adjusting to climate change has led to an unprecedented push for replacing fossil fuel sources with renewable energies. Offshore windfarms will provide a significant proportion of that energy as wind conditions, safety and visual impact are more favourable offshore than onshore. Typical windfarms harness the power of several dozen wind turbines by transmitting the generated power to a single High Voltage transformer to increase the transmission voltage to several 100 kVs and exporting it to shore. The transformer and the export cable are often the costliest single ticket elements of such an offshore development, and with the increasing distance to shore of new developments, these costs increase. Superconducting transmission cables are an opportunity to either decrease those costs by transporting the power at lower voltage (and thus saving on the transformer units) or creating bulk transmission cables that funnel multi-GW power from several windfarms. Superconducting cables have been used industrially onshore for more than a decade but mostly in urban environments where their higher per-metre cost is offset by savings on real estate (narrow right-of-way, smaller/fewer transformers). Superconducting cables need to operate at a temperature of 77K/-196°C or less to be effective. This is achieved by installing the cable inside a double-walled pipeline (cryostat) that allows flowing liquid nitrogen (LN2) along the cable while minimizing heat ingress from the environment. Based on its technology for LNG, ITP has developed a thermomechanical design for a reeled, cryogenic pipe-in-pipe hosting superconducting power cables. A newly constructed high-precision cryogenic test bench validates the thermal performance. The author will present the design of the cryogenic envelope and key figures for its integration into a windfarm. Results obtained from a test campaign on a full-scale (8”/16”) cryogenic pipe-in-pipe provide the thermal and mechanical data to discuss the constructability of the system.
-
Authors: Didier Hanonge, TechnipFMC France / Jean Paul Ferraz and Romain Ferre, TechnipFMC Brazil
CO₂-induced Stress Corrosion Cracking (CO₂-SCC) was reported by ANP (National Petroleum Agency - Brazil) in 2017 after the failure of a flexible riser operating in a severe CO₂ environment. This was a major challenge for operators in Brazil extensive pre-salt fields where flexible pipes have and will continue to play an important role. Since then, an extensive program has been executed providing a plethora of small and full scale test results. CO₂- SCC has been reproduced on all families of carbon steels, demonstrating the robustness of the test procedures. This major accomplishment allowed to build safe domains which have been certified. Those domains are defined by the maximum local stress acting on the wire and the CO₂ content, which are the main parameters, that can cause CO₂-SCC to initiate in presence of water. In addition, progress have been made in the modelling of the diffusion process of the gas species from the bore into the pipe annulus. The complexity of the flexible pipe annulus has been included in the diffusion methodology. New tools, allowing to precisely assess total local stresses on armour wires, considering the manufacturing process, were also developed. Risk assessment of pipes operating outside this SCC Free domain is addressed by a new and inventive methodology. This approach is based on dissection of pipes recovered from field and fracture mechanics theory and allows to evaluate the service life of those lines operating in severe conditions. The objective of this paper is to present the breakthrough progress in the CO₂-SCC understanding, allowing the safe design of flexible pipes against this new failure mode.
-
Authors: Asli Yazici, Senior Structural Engineer and Rahul Raghukumar, Senior Pipeline Engineer, IRM Systems
Co-authors: Rutger Schouten, MD, IRM Systems and Ulrich Tiefes, Head of Pipeline Engineering, Wintershall NoordzeeIn the recent years, the need for continuing operations with aging assets has increased highly. The Operators are now looking for ways to use data effectively for optimizing pipeline operations to obtain more control over aging assets and support leaner operations in order to lower the operating costs.
Wintershall Noordzee and IRM Systems jointly developed a risk-based inspection (RBI) methodology for offshore pipelines which overruled the conventional time-based inspection methodology. The risk-based inspection strategy was implemented on a digital platform indigenously developed by IRM Systems called PIBOT¹ to suit Wintershall Noordzee’s requirements. The capabilities of the digital platform were data analysis, degradation forecasting, integrity assessment, risk assessment, survey optimization and automated report generation.
The risks assessment was performed based on a quantitative approach in accordance with the internationally recognised standards. The PoF² and CoF³ determination was automated by the software using decision trees, and their values were re-calculated when new inspection results were uploaded into the digital platform along with the updated operational data. The PIBOT calculates the risk profiles along the pipeline based on the Structural and Third-Party Threats, the results of which are presented on GIS System and linked to the Wintershall Noordzee Risk Matrix. The outcome is used to select the inspection intervals. The RBI implementation helps to increase the efficiency of data management/interpretation and provides the opportunity to focus on high-risk sections of the pipeline. Automating this process using PIBOT assures significant OPEX reduction for Wintershall Noordzee Asset Management.
-
Authors: Stephen Cater, Principal Project Leader, TWI Technology Centre and Santonu Ghosh, R&D Project Lead for Strategic Projects, Element Six UK Ltd
Joining steel by welding is one of the crucial technologies in all fabrication, including subsea pipelines, and arc welding has long been the leading technology for that application. Recent advances made by Element Six in the development of new FSW tool materials are now allowing the transfer of the proven benefits of FSW to steel to begin. This paper outlines how the new generation of E6 tools allows consistently good welds to be made in a range of steels typical of those used in the pipeline sector. Initial work was performed to demonstrate that tools used for fabrication in 6mm thick carbon steels had a consistent and useful life of up to 60m of weld, and that the welds produced were defect free. The tools were then further developed to permit welds to be made, in a single pass, in steels up to 12mm thick, with the potential to move to greater thicknesses should the market demonstrate that need. In addition, work has demonstrated additional advantages the E6 PCBN tools bring to the friction stir welding process in steel, including the ability to:
• Enhance the strength of the welds made
• Join hard to weld grades, and to make dissimilar welds between carbon and stainless steels
• Weld under water and in oil
• Potentially enhance the fatigue life of existing structures by friction stir processing their existing arc welds
• Use the friction stir processing technique to aid in rehabilitating pipelines for the transport of hydrogen & CO2. -
Authors: Renaud Dessaint, Renaud Phelut and Mickael Guignon, TechnipFMC
This paper aims to present an update of the cost effective and versatile smooth carcass technology development, the advanced carcass geometry that improves flow assurance performances and suppresses possible occurrence of Flow Induced Pulsation (FLIP). This paper reviews the smooth carcass principles and advantages, presents the thorough qualification including a full-scale dynamic test, certification achievements and growing manufacturing track record. Based on a FMECA, a qualification program, in compliance with API 17J & B, covers the whole life cycle of a flexible pipe. This is built jointly with the involvement of a third party that witnesses the whole process, confirming the robustness of the overall approach.
Engineering, prototypes manufacturing and full-scale tests campaign validated successfully the static applications. For the qualification towards dynamic applications, a test program has been established on the basis of a gap analysis with respect to specificities introduced compared to conventional carcass. It resulted in performing medium, and full-scale dynamic test representative of dynamic field conditions. Certification is now achieved. Manufacturing track record includes today flexibles from 8 to 14in ID with austenitic and duplex materials of several sizes, over more than 20 km in total, beyond 1,000 meters water depth.
This paper presents the final steps of qualification and certification for dynamic applications, jointly with the large envelop of manufacturing capability demonstrated through project delivery. It further substantiates the robustness of the smooth carcass technology enabling risers and flowlines to reach best-in-class flow assurance performances, while also preventing any risk of FLIP.
-
Authors: Alastair Walker, Advanced Mechanics & Engineering Pty, Ltd and Pieter Swart, SeaLeopard Engineering BV
As part of the pipeline pre-commissioning, the objective of a system pressure test (a.k.a. Hydrotest) is to prove a pipeline installed on the seabed is capable of containing a pre-determined test pressure at an environmental temperature without bursting or collapse of the pipeline and evidence of leakage of the test water. The test pressure is usually related to the maximum operating pressure times a design factor specified in the pipeline design basis. While the application of a hydrotest strength test has been common practice during the past five decades, today’s technology developments’, realized in the past 3 decades, have significantly contributed to high levels reliability in the design, fabrication and installation processes. So, the question is warranted – can the high cost, critical path execution schedule delay and the environmental damage of the hydrotest be avoided? Can we replace the hydrotest, and with what? The paper describes the difficulties, schedule delays and likely costs entailed when carrying out a full-scale hydrotest and is considering an alternative approach to assessing the safety of the as-installed pipeline. It addresses the practical aspects of a hydrotest and discusses an alternative approach. While not compromising the safety of operating the as-installed pipeline, the alternative safety assessment is presented using existing quality of the design, manufacturing and installation technologies. The paper presents some examples for various circumstances.
To request a copy of the full paper please complete the application form.